Is An ESOP Right For Your Company?
Originally published: 08.01.07 by Mike Coyne
An employee stock ownership plan can provide cash to the owner and a future to the business.
Tom, age 49, owns an hvacr business with 30 employees. Tom's personal financial adviser is concerned that most of his net worth is tied up in the business and has suggested that Tom begin to diversify. Likewise, the company's attorney is concerned with the company's succession plan. Tom knows of several employees who could succeed him, given more time to learn the business and work together. He doubts, however, that these employees could raise the money necessary to buy him out. Tom needs to consider an employee stock ownership plan, known as an ESOP.
An ESOP is an employee benefit plan that primarily invests in employer stock, thereby making the employees of a company the beneficial owners of the stock in that company. Because the ESOP is an employee benefit plan, it is subject to certain rules contained in the Internal Revenue Code and Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA).
One of the most common uses of an ESOP is to buy the stock of an owner in a closely held company. An ESOP can provide a market for the equity of a shareholder of
ESOPs are beneficial for both the selling shareholders and the employees if done right. Education and communication are vital to the ESOP's success. ESOPs work best for companies with 20 or more employees, with revenues sufficient to warrant the added ESOP expense and for companies that desire to foster an ownership culture.
Selling shares to an ESOP does not happen overnight. It requires careful, thoughtful planning and analysis. The process is very similar to selling the business to a third party, except the third party in this transaction is the ESOP.
Feasibility Study and Fiduciary
The first step in selling shares to an ESOP is to conduct a feasibility study to determine whether the company can afford the ESOP loan payments and distribution payments to the participants. The feasibility study requires an in-depth analysis of the company's financial health and prospects for growth as well as consideration of the stability of the company's workforce.
Once the feasibility study is completed and reviewed, the company must hire an independent or transactional fiduciary, or trustee, to represent the ESOP. This is to assure that the ESOP is treated fairly in the stock purchase transaction. The fiduciary will conduct due diligence and negotiate the terms and price of the purchase of stock. The ESOP may only purchase the shares for "adequate consideration" as defined by the Department of Labor (DOL) and Internal Revenue Service (IRS). Adequate consideration is determined, in part, by (1) an independent appraisal prepared by a qualified ESOP appraiser hired by the fiduciary and (2) the fiduciary reviewing the independent appraisal to ensure that reasonable assumptions were made by the appraiser and that the independent appraisal is accurate, complete, reasonable, and complies with the DOL and IRS rules.
Structuring The Sale
The sale of the shares can be structured in various ways. The selling shareholders can simply sell the shares and obtain capital gains tax treatment on the sale. Alternatively, Section 1042 of the Internal Revenue Code permits owners of closely held companies (which are taxed as C corporations) to incur no taxable gain on the sale of stock to an ESOP. However, there are numerous restrictions and conditions that apply in order to obtain this favorable tax treatment. For example, if the selling shareholder elects Section 1042 treatment, he cannot be a participant in the ESOP. It is not necessary for an owner to sell all of his stock to the ESOP, although a complete sale is not uncommon.
The sale of the stock to an ESOP may be leveraged or non-leveraged. In a leveraged ESOP, the ESOP or its corporate sponsor borrows money from a bank or other qualified lender. The company usually gives the lender a guarantee that it will make contributions to the trust, which will enable the trust to pay off the loan; or, if the lender prefers, the company may borrow directly and make a loan back to the ESOP. The leveraging will be used to buy out the stock of the former owners, and the ESOP will acquire those shares.
Two tax incentives make borrowing through an ESOP extremely attractive to companies. First, because ESOP contributions are tax deductible, the corporation is able to deduct principal payments as well as interest payments from taxes. This can cut the cost of financing to the company significantly. Second, dividends paid on ESOP stock of a C corporation whether passed through to employees, reinvested by employees for more company stock, or used to repay the ESOP loan also are tax deductible. This provision of federal tax law may increase the amount of cash available to a company compared with one utilizing conventional financing. See the schematic of a leveraged ESOP on page 12.
In a leveraged ESOP, the cash would flow as follows:
- The company would make plan contributions to the ESOP.
- The ESOP pays on the promissory note to company. When the shares are paid, they are allocated in the ESOP to the plan participants.
- The company pays on the promissory note to the bank.
Let's go back to Tom's situation, described in the beginning of this article. The company hired an independent fiduciary to negotiate the sale of Tom's shares to the ESOP. Because Tom is continuing in the business and has an interest in its future success, Tom decides against the 1042 treatment. Tom will pay capital gains tax but also will participate in the ESOP. Tom believes his participation in the ESOP is meaningful to the employees and sends the employees the message that they are all in this together. Because Tom did not take 1042 treatment, he also agreed to seller-finance the sale to give the ESOP a longer term to payoff the debt than the proposed bank financing (10 years vs. 7 years) and a lower interest rate than the bank financing (7.5% vs. 8%). Because Tom was being paid over 10 years, he agreed to sell all his shares to the ESOP.
The company, now 100% owned by the ESOP, elects to become a subchapter S corporation. This means that there no longer will be any tax at the corporate level — all of the company profits pass through to the owner. Because the owner is an ESOP, which is tax exempt, no income tax is paid on any of the company's profits! Through this process Tom has increased the company's cash flow by 35% (the amount that would otherwise be paid out in federal taxes).
Ensuring Success Early
The success of an ESOP depends, in part, on company philosophy and employee involvement. Considerations in adopting an ESOP should include: How will the employees view the sale? Employee communication and involvement early in the process is key. Many organizations assist businesses with employee communications. Among them are: The ESOP Association, NCEO (National Center for Employee Ownership), and the Ohio Employee Ownership Center at Kent State University.
Tom involved those key employees identified early on in the entire process so that the transaction was a group effort and group success. The company used services from some of the organizations mentioned above to assist with employee communication and education. The company's key employees continue to serve on the trustee and administration committees and attend annual ESOP workshops and seminars. These actions further the goal of developing Tom's successors within the business.
Once an ESOP is established, it is important to maintain successful management. Therefore, many ESOP companies will implement a management incentive program. Frequently, nonqualified deferred compensation plans are implemented to maintain key management (golden handcuffs) and/or to cover those individuals that are not receiving comparable benefits provided in a pre-ESOP retirement plan. The existence of the ESOP does not prevent the company from continuing existing nonqualified plans or implementing new ones.
When considering an ESOP, it is never too early to consider the ESOP repurchase obligation. Since the participants cannot sell their closely held stock on an open market, the ESOP/company must provide the market and repurchase the shares. The cost for repurchasing the shares must be factored into whether an ESOP will work in a particular company. Consideration must be given to the repurchase obligation projections for death, disability, retirement, diversification, and other termination for the next 10 to 15 years. What is the company's workforce composition? Is there high or low turnover? Can the company handle the obligation and still maintain desired growth? Too large a repurchase obligation in proportion to available cash flow can stifle a company's ability to modernize and compete in the long term. The corporation can adopt a funding plan within the ESOP or outside the ESOP — such as accumulating cash inside the ESOP, the company purchasing life insurance on participants with high account balances, pay-as-you-go, or establish a sinking fund (a cash reserve in the corporation for purposes of paying down the debt).
Consideration should also be given to the impact on the company's other retirement plans. Will the company continue providing benefits in the other retirement plans? This will depend on company philosophy, cash flow, and IRS deduction limits. Most companies discontinue company contributions in other retirement plans and treat the ESOP as the replacement. However, the companies do maintain the 401(k) plan, permitting deferrals but scaling back matches.
Finally, there are special S corporation ESOP considerations. Analysis has shown that the long-term tax savings generated by S corporation ESOP companies can be significantly greater than for some C corporations. Due to the tax-free nature of the S corporation ESOP, there are complicated calculations that must be performed each year to ensure that the ESOP benefits a broad range of employees and that the ownership is not concentrated in the hands of a few employees.
1. Qualified securities are defined as common stock of a C corporation with voting and dividend rights equal to the classes of common stock having the greatest voting and dividend rights. The securities must have been owned by the seller for at least three years and cannot have been received by the seller in a distribution from a qualified retirement plan or a transfer under a stock option granted by the company.
2. Qualified replacement property is defined as any security issued by a domestic operating corporation that is not the corporation that issued the qualified securities that were sold to the ESOP (or a member of the same controlled group of corporations), and which does not receive more than 25% of its gross receipts during the taxable year in which it is purchased from passive investment (this requirement disqualifies mutual funds). Government securities and securities acquired by an underwriter do not qualify. An operating corporation is one whose assets are used in the active conduct of a trade or business. Passive income has the same meaning as under the S corporation rules.
Michael P. Coyne is a founding partner of the law firm Waldheger Coyne, located in Cleveland, OH. For more information of the firm, visit: www.healthlaw.com or call 440.835.0600.
Articles by Mike Coyne
How to Be a Savvy Negotiator for Commercial Leases
Consider more than just the rental rate when evaluating commercial property and negotiating leases.
Carefully Consider Coverage for Liability
Too often, customers do not appreciate that such demands for protection against damages cannot be accommodated without exceptional costs that translate into significantly higher prices for services.
Tactics for Avoiding Lawsuits
Litigation is always the result of a failure of people to deal with each other reasonably.
How to Take Control From Minority Shareholders
Rules for Retaining Tax Records
An explanation and some clarity on the IRS guidelines